One Iranian pro-democracy activist was handcuffed, bundled onto a plane and flown 11,000 kilometres to the conflict-hit Central African Republic – a country she didn’t know existed – after she’d been granted legal protection in the US.
She is one of the more than 25,000 people who’ve been deported to countries that are not their own, and to which they have no ties, since January 2025, according to an investigation by Forbidden Stories. Peruvians and Colombians have been sent to the Democratic Republic of Congo, Russians and Chinese to Costa Rica, and Vietnamese and Jamaicans to Eswatini (formerly Swaziland).
The policy targets people who cannot be returned to their country of origin due to a risk of persecution, or because that nation has refused to take them. Trump’s workaround has been instead to find other countries willing to accept them, negotiating shady multi-million-dollar deals behind closed doors. Once there, deportees have been detained, assaulted and left without support or status – while others have been sent onwards to the dangerous home countries they fled.
Putting people in restraints and banishing them to countries thousands of kilometres from anywhere they’ve ever known is a form of punishment more fitting to a bygone era. But it cannot be dismissed as a uniquely Trumpian aberration.
Britain’s former Conservative government pursued a similar policy – most notoriously through its Rwanda scheme, which was eventually ditched after a years-long legal battle and public opposition. Israel secretly operated a version of the scheme between 2013 and 2018, sending asylum-seekers from Eritrea and Sudan to Rwanda and Uganda. Most left within days of arrival, embarking on dangerous journeys towards Europe facilitated by smugglers. Australia’s policy of exiling asylum-seekers in offshore processing centres in Nauru and Papua New Guinea created a system of rampant abuse and psychological torture.
These experiences should be a warning. Yet as evidence of the devastating human cost of Trump’s third-country removals mounts, European countries are moving in a similar direction.
On 1 October, the Council of the European Union gave the final green light to new rules allowing member states to establish ‘deportation hubs’ in third countries outside the bloc. Greece, Germany, Austria, the Netherlands and Denmark have already announced plans to set up a hub in Rwanda, to deposit people with ‘no right to stay in the EU’. Swedish far-right MEP Charlie Weimers gleefully greeted the new approach with the declaration: ‘The era of deportations has begun.’ It all feels depressingly familiar.
While the ‘EU Return Regulation’ might contain safeguards that Trump’s banishment policy has ignored, it’s inevitable that people who have a right to protection under international law will be targeted.
Europe is embarking on a dangerous race to the bottom on migration rights: the externalization of borders through migration deals with countries like Tunisia and Egypt, the escalation of pushbacks in Greece, Poland and even Finland, and increasingly unhinged attempts to make migration more difficult, dangerous and invisible. Bypassing refugee protections is fast becoming the norm, rather than the exception.
This approach also has further-reaching