Donation Amount. Min £2

Times Tower, Kenya Revenue Authority headquarters in Nairobi. File I Nation Media Group

The High Court has thrown out a case in which the Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) sought to collect Sh900 million from soft drinks manufacturer Coca-Cola. 

Justice Chacha Mwita upheld the decision of the Tax Appeals Tribunal to block the KRA from demanding the tax from Coca-Cola Central East and West Africa Limited.

The dispute involved VAT input refund on export services related to marketing and promotion of the Coca-Cola brands in Kenya through vernacular media stations and roadshows.

 

The judge upheld the tribunal’s finding that the beverages maker paid the disputed VAT in the USA following the service agreement between Coca-Cola Africa and Coca-Cola Export.

The Coca-Cola Export, which was based in the USA, commissioned the agreement with Coca-Cola Africa based in Kenya to promote through advertising, Coca-Cola brands to local potential customers.

“I, therefore, agree with the Tax Appeals Tribunal that in accordance with the destination principle, this was an export service and the USA had the taxing rights,” said Justice Mwita.

The dispute started after Coca-Cola Africa applied for a refund of input VAT in 2017 for Sh903,182,037.

Destination principle

The Commissioner of Domestic Taxes audited Coca-Cola Africa’s VAT returns for April 2014 to June 2016, a period during which Coca-Cola Africa had undertaken customised advertising in Kenyan local dialects through the media, roadshows, and brand activation.

The Commissioner issued preliminary findings disallowing Sh725,082,158 from the claim for input VAT due to undeclared output tax on locally consumed services and local sales. 

Coca-Cola Africa explained the services supplied to Coca-Cola Export were exported services and thus exempted from VAT.

However, the Commissioner confirmed its findings in an assessment dated June 15, 2017, and upheld his decision that the marketing and promotion services attracted VAT at the general rate of 16 percent and that his assessment was final.

But Coca-Cola Africa objected, setting the stage for the legal dispute that went to the tribunal after the parties failed to resolve the issues in a technical forum.

Mr Van Der Part, a witness for Coca-Cola Africa, pointed out that charging VAT on business-to-business marketing services would result in double taxation.

For his part, the Commissioner argued that although the marketing and promotion services were provided to Coca-Cola Export, a foreign company, the service was consumed in Kenya and was, therefore, subject to VAT.

In his judgment, Justice Mwita said that consumers in Kenya were not receiving any service from Coca-Cola Africa in the course of marketing.

“Consumption, if any, would come in only after Coca-Cola Export decided what to do with the brands that had been marketed and promoted, or if the brands were offered for sale usually on a future date,” said the judge.

He also upheld the tribunal’s finding that although marketing and promotion took place in Kenya, there was no proof that every Kenyan who saw the adverts purchased a beverage.

According to the tribunal, the test was where the consumer was located, and agreed with Coca-Cola Africa, that the public in Kenya was the target audience of the advertising and promotion services. But the benefit accrued to Coca-Cola Export for purposes of enhancing the business of sales. By Joseph Wangui, NMG

About IEA Media Ltd

Informer East Africa is a UK based diaspora Newspaper. It is a unique platform connecting East Africans at home and abroad through news dissemination. It is a forum to learn together, grow together and get entertained at the same time.

To advertise events or products, get in touch by info [at] informereastafrica [dot] com or call +447957636854.
If you have an issue or a story, get in touch with the editor through editor[at] informereastafrica [dot] com or call +447886544135.

We also accept donations from our supporters. Please click on "donate". Your donations will go along way in supporting the newspaper.

Get in touch

Our Offices

London, UK
+44 7886 544135
editor (@) informereastafrica.com
Slough, UK
+44 7957 636854
info (@) informereastafrica.com

Latest News

Kenya tops global ranking for social media use

Kenya tops global ra...

 Kenya has emerged as the country where individuals spend the most time on social media, a new repor...

Somalia’s Electoral Reform Plans Face Skepticism Despite Government Push

Somalia’s Electoral...

Somalia’s recent push for democratic reforms through a one-person, one-vote (OPOV) electoral system...

Dr Denis Mukwege: We Must Restore Dignity Of Victims Of Sexual Violence

Dr Denis Mukwege: We...

Displaced community members who have fled the M23 conflict speak during a Doctors Without Borders ....

Sudan scraps $6 billion UAE port deal, citing RSF support

Sudan scraps $6 bill...

Sudan has cancelled a $6 billion deal with the United Arab Emirates to develop a Red Sea port, Finan...

For Advertisement

Big Reach

Informer East Africa is one platform for all people. It is a platform where you find so many professionals under one umbrella serving the African communities together.

Very Flexible

We exist to inform you, hear from you and connect you with what is happening around you. We do this professionally and timely as we endeavour to capture all that you should never miss. Informer East Africa is simply news for right now and the future.

Quality News

We only bring to you news that is verified, checked and follows strict journalistic guidelines and standards. We believe in 1. Objective coverage, 2. Impartiality and 3. Fair play.

Banner & Video Ads

A banner & video advertisement from our sponsors will show up every once in a while. It keeps us and our writers coffee replenished.